Should I Renovate Or Demolish My House in Canada?

by Richard Morrison
June 20, 2022
Buyers
0

re you wondering if it’s time to renovate or demolish your house? It can be a difficult decision with so much at stake. This article will explore the pros and cons of both options, helping you decide which is best for you.

I know first-hand how daunting this situation can feel; I had to make the same tough choice myself recently. But after researching my options and weighing up all the factors involved, I was able to come to an informed conclusion that suited my client best. And hopefully, by reading this article, you’ll be able to do the same!

Table of Contents show

Quick Summary

When deciding whether to renovate or demolish a house in Canada, factors such as age and condition of the house, cost of renovation, demolition and rebuilding should be taken into account. Heritage or conservation value and regulatory restrictions should also be considered, however, as it may constrict the outcome. Combining demolition and construction into one project might be more economical. A thorough assessment of costs and advantages of each option should be done before making a decision.

Cost to Demolish a House in BC

The expense associated with house demolition in British Columbia (BC) may fluctuate based on various factors like the house’s size, its geographical placement, and the presence of any dangerous substances. Based on research findings, the inclusive cost for mitigation and demolition can range anywhere between $15,000 to $40,000, with the costs potentially increasing for larger homes.

The recent tearing down of a 2,000-square-foot home in Vancouver came with a price tag of around $68,000 – with approximately $20,000 of that amount being spent on debris removal.

On average, the demolition costs for existing homes where hazardous materials are discovered typically range between $20,000 and $50,000.

Costs to Renovate a House in BC

The expense associated with renovating a house in British Columbia (BC) can fluctuate based on numerous aspects. A survey by CIBC revealed that in 2019, 49% of Canadians intended to renovate their homes with an average budget of $10,211. Nevertheless, this broad-based estimate doesn’t consider factors like the renovation’s scale and intricacy, the age of the house, or the workmanship quality.

In British Columbia, you can expect to pay anywhere from $19,800 to $73,200 for a home renovation, averaging between $15 and $60 per square foot. Nonetheless, the final price tag can fluctuate based on the extent of the renovation and the specific area being updated. For instance, a significant kitchen makeover might set you back about $50,000 or even more, factoring in materials, labor, and professional fees.

Top Reasons to Consider Home Renovation

Renovations are exciting. You can improve something already there—the possibilities are endless! Renovating is a popular way to improve your home.

It lets you decorate each room creatively. More importantly, it lets you customize everything from colours and textures to furniture placement and lighting fixtures to countertop material. Renovation allows for energy-efficient windows and appliances. These upgrades improve comfort, convenience, and resale value if you move.

After discussing why people might renovate rather than demolish their homes, let’s examine the financial implications of each.

Financial Factors to Consider When Deciding Between Renovation and Demolition

Financial factors matter when choosing between renovating or demolishing my house. Each option’s costs must fit my budget.

How much work needs to be done and what materials and appliances I use will determine renovation costs.
Demolition costs include taking down the house, removing debris, and fixing any damage. It’s also important for me to review my financial situation, including whether I have enough saved up for a large project like this.
If I need additional financing, if debt consolidation would help ease payments over time, and if my house insurance covers renovation or demolition costs.

Considering all these will help me decide which route is financially feasible so I can proceed with confidence. Before making any decisions, I need to assess my house’s structure…

Assessing the Structural Integrity of Your Home

Choosing between renovating or demolishing your home is difficult. Before choosing, check the building’s structure. Five things to consider when assessing your home’s structure:

Look for cracks, sagging floors and ceilings, and water damage.
Check all electrical and plumbing fixtures for safety and adequacy.
Assess insulation levels and energy efficiency.
Check windows and doors for wear and rot and decide if they need replacing. Investigate safety hazards like rotting wood or exposed wires.

To estimate the cost of renovating or demolishing your house, you must also factor in the cost of repairing or replacing damaged items. An experienced contractor can evaluate your home’s structure to help you decide which financial option is best. Let’s examine building demolition’s pros and cons.

Advantages and Disadvantages of Demolishing a Structure

Renovating or demolishing a house can be tricky. Before tearing down a building, weigh the pros and cons.

Demolition saves money. Starting from scratch may be cheaper than restoring an old home, depending on its age and condition. Tearing down lets you build something new that meets all your needs without dealing with foundations or other renovation issues. Destroying old, energy-inefficient parts of the building can also save energy.

Demolition has some significant drawbacks. The biggest drawback is environmental impact. Destroying buildings creates a lot of waste, and they often contain asbestos, which must be safely removed and disposed of to comply with local laws. Before starting a demolition project, you should research zoning laws and paperwork.

Navigating Zoning Laws and Obtaining Required Permits

Before deciding to demolish or renovate your house, learn about zoning and permits. Before acting, check with city officials to make sure you’re meeting all requirements. Demolition and renovation may be restricted in your area. Research beforehand to avoid surprises.

If you plan to demolish your home instead of renovating it, make sure you understand how much debris will need to be disposed of and what fees may apply.

In order to comply with local laws, hiring a professional for demolition and clean-up is usually necessary. Homeowners can avoid major issues by assessing the situation upfront.

READ MORE: Are Home Improvement Worth it?? – Home Renovation Tax Credits

Estimating the Cost of Home Demolition

Estimating home demolition costs can be difficult. You can estimate the cost of demolishing your house with some research and understanding.

Size, age, construction materials, local demolition laws and regulations, access points or roadways, land elevation changes, underground utilities, etc. affect the cost ofdemolishinga home. When getting professional demolition quotes, consider all these.

You may also need to consider landfill fees and environmental cleanup costs if hazardous materials are found. Request an itemized cost estimate before starting the project to avoid surprises.

After estimating the cost of demolishing a home, let’s look at how to safely remove building materials without damaging anything.

Safe Methods for Removing Construction Materials

Consider how you’ll safely remove building materials before demolishing your house. Demolition debris removal is difficult and requires safe demolition techniques.

Demolition involves removing hazardous material first, sorting salvageable items from non-salvageable items, and disposing of hazardous waste in an environmentally friendly manner.
Consider what will happen to all the building materials after they are removed. Asbestos and lead paint may be regulated in your area. Before demolishing, check local building material disposal laws.
Check with your local recycling centres to see if they accept recycled building materials. Knowing which recycling centres accept these materials can save time later.

Building materials can be safely and efficiently removed with proper planning and safety. Let’s examine property tax effects of home demolition.

How Demolishing a Home Affects Property Taxes

Did you know that demolishing an old home can reduce property taxes by 40%? That’s significant money. Before demolishing or renovating your house, it’s important to understand how property taxes will change.

The following scenarios affect your tax bill:

Situation	Tax Impact
Renovate House	No Change
Demolish and Rebuild	Higher Taxes
Donate Home for Historic Preservation	Lower Taxes

If you stay in your home but renovate, your property tax bill will likely not change. If you demolish and rebuild, your home’s value will likely rise, resulting in higher taxes. However, local regulations may lower taxes if you donate your home for historic preservation.

When choosing a financial option, keep in mind that demolishing a home may require additional paperwork, permits, and fees, depending on your state and local laws. When deciding between renovation and demolition, all these factors affect your property tax bill.

Frequently Asked Questions

What Is The Average Timeline For A Renovation Project?

Here are some things to consider when determining your own renovation timeline:

Costs – Renovations can be expensive so make sure you have enough money saved up before beginning any work.
Time Required – It takes longer than expected for even simple projects due to delays in obtaining materials, waiting for permits and inspections, etc., which all adds up over time.
Project Management – If you’re doing most of the work yourself, then it might take longer as well since you won’t have access to professional contractors who can get jobs done quickly and efficiently.

No matter what kind of renovation project you’re undertaking, always plan ahead and set realistic expectations by researching local building codes, getting multiple bids from contractors, shopping around for supplies, and allowing extra time just in case something unexpected arises during construction.

What Are The Environmental Considerations Of Demolishing A Home?

As well as these direct impacts, the energy used in both demolition and new construction must also be accounted for; if electricity is being generated by non-renewable sources then this could have serious long-term consequences.

The best way to minimize your carbon footprint while demolishing or renovating is by making sure all building materials are disposed of responsibly – recycling wherever possible – and using renewable energy sources whenever available.

Are There Any DIY Demolition Options Available?

Here are four things to consider before attempting a DIY project:

Safety – Make sure to wear protective gear such as gloves, goggles, and dust masks when handling hazardous materials.
Logistics – Ensure you have all the supplies needed for the job and plan out how you will get rid of debris after completing the project.
Environmental Considerations – Be mindful of local environmental regulations when performing your own demolition work at home.
Cost – While DIY demolition can save money upfront, it’s important to factor in other costs like renting equipment or disposal fees which could add up quickly depending on the size of the project.

Are There Any Incentives For Renovating Or Demolishing A Home?

From grants that promote energy efficiency improvements through home renovation projects, to tax credits and other initiatives designed to offset the costs of materials used during demolition – there’s a range of options available depending on where you live and what kind of project you’re hoping to accomplish.

Even if your local government doesn’t offer any specific programs related to renovations or demolitions, they may have some kind of incentive program that could prove useful.

What Are The Best Ways To Find A Reliable Contractor For A Renovation Or Demolition Project?

A great place to begin is by talking with people in your network – family, friends, neighbors – who have had similar projects completed recently. They may be able to provide referrals from contractors they’ve worked with before or heard good things about.

Checking out online reviews is another invaluable way of learning more about different companies and their customer service. Additionally, professional organizations such as the Canadian Home Builders‘ Association (CHBA) and local trade groups offer directories of qualified professionals that meet stringent standards established by these associations.

Finally, interviewing multiple contractors will allow you to get a better sense of how well each person understands your goals and budget for the job at hand.

What is the difference between rebuilding and remodeling?

A: Rebuilding refers to tearing down the existing structure and constructing a new house in its place. Remodeling, on the other hand, involves making significant changes to the interior and sometimes the exterior of the existing house without completely knocking it down.

Is it cheaper to knock downand rebuild or remodel my house?

A: It depends on the extent of renovations needed and the cost of materials and labor in your area. In some cases, demolishing and rebuilding might be more cost-effective than extensive remodeling, especially if the existing structure is in poor condition.

How does tearing down my house and building a new one compare to remodeling from a sustainability point of view?

A: Building a new house allows you to incorporate energy-efficient features and modern materials that can significantly reduce your energy consumption. However, remodeling can also be sustainable if you focus on improving insulation, using eco-friendly materials, and upgrading mechanical systems.

What should I consider before deciding to renovate or knock down my house?

A: Some factors to consider include the condition of your current home, your budget, your long-term plans for the property, the historical significance of the house, the availability of contractors in your area, and any local regulations or setback requirements.

Can I reuse materials from my old house if I decide to bring down and rebuild?

A: Yes, you can salvage and reuse certain materials like doors, windows, fixtures, and even structural components if they are in good condition. This can help reduce waste and lower the overall cost of the project.

Are there any advantages to building a new house instead of remodeling?

A: Building a new house allows you to have complete control over the design and layout. Additionally, it can be more cost-effective if the existing structure requires extensive repairs or if you want a more energy-efficient home.

Should I hire a contractor for the renovation or demolition project?

A: It is highly recommended to hire a reputable contractor who specializes in renovations or demolitions, depending on your chosen approach. They can help ensure that the project is done properly, according to local regulations, and within a reasonable timeframe.

What are some potential challenges I may face when renovating an old house?

A: Renovating an old house can come with its own set of challenges such as dealing with outdated wiring or plumbing, addressing structural issues, encountering unexpected problems during the renovation process, and working within the limitations of the existing layout.

Is it better to renovate a historically significant home or bring down and rebuild?

A: If your house has historical significance, it is recommended to consult with the local municipality or historical preservation society before making a decision. They can provide guidance on the best course of action while preserving the historical integrity of the property.

Conclusion

In conclusion, deciding whether to renovate or bring down your home is a big decision. Depending on the size and scope of the project, it could take months or even years.

You should carefully consider all aspects like environmental impacts, cost savings incentives, and DIY options before making any decisions.

To make sure you get the best experience possible out of this process, be sure to do your research and hire a reliable contractor who will help bring your vision to life.

Sources:

https://www.thestar.com/life/homes/opinion/2019/01/19/cant-decide-if-you-should-renovate-or-rebuild.html

https://www.theglobeandmail.com/real-estate/article-when-does-it-make-sense-to-renovate-instead-of-buy/

Ready to turn your real estate dreams into reality? Contact Richard Morrison, Vancouver’s top realtor with 20+ years of experience. As a Medallion Club member and RE/MAX Hall of Fame award winning agent, he’s the expert you need on your side. Whether buying, selling, or investing, Richard’s personalized approach and deep market insights ensure a successful transaction. Reach out to Richard today at (778) 900-2235 and make your real estate journey seamless and rewarding.

Lets Have a Smart Conversation.

Let's Chat! Looking for a REALTOR© who can exceed your expectations? Look no further than Richard Morrison! His mission is to serve without limit & provide solutions that cater to your core needs.
* 20+ Years of Experience
* Medallion Member
* RE/MAX Hall of Fame

Date

Time

Your Contact Details

Name

Phone

Message

Your Privacy is important to us. View our Privacy & Data Collection Policy.

Latest Vancouver Listings

Bed: 1Bath: 1Built in 1997638 sqft

5 days ago

Bed: 1Bath: 1Built in 1997638 sqft

South Vancouver simply affordable one-bedroom home features spacious...

$499,800

MLS®: R2828287 • Royal Pacific Realty (Kings...